Allegation of Research Misconduct

Jurnal Pendidikan Matematika takes all allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously. Allegations are handled confidentially, fairly, and promptly, following the COPE flowcharts and the COPE Core Practices.

What counts as misconduct

  • Fabrication – making up data or results;
  • Falsification – manipulating research materials, data, images, or processes, or omitting data so that results are misrepresented;
  • Plagiarism – using another person's ideas, text, data, or work without proper citation, including self-plagiarism (text recycling) and translation plagiarism;
  • Duplicate or redundant publication and simultaneous submission to several journals;
  • Authorship misconduct – ghost, guest, or purchased authorship;
  • Citation manipulation – excessive self-citation or citation stacking;
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest;
  • Ethical violations involving research participants – for example, collecting data from students or teachers without informed consent or required institutional/school permission;
  • Peer review manipulation, and undisclosed or inappropriate use of AI tools.

How to report a concern

Anyone (readers, reviewers, authors, editors, or institutions) may raise a concern by emailing the Editor-in-Chief at jupitek@mail.unpatti.ac.id. Please include the article title or submission ID, a clear description of the concern, and any supporting evidence. Anonymous reports will be considered if they contain enough specific evidence to investigate.

How allegations are handled

  1. Initial assessment – The Editor-in-Chief (or an independent editor if the Editor-in-Chief has a conflict) checks whether the concern is substantive and within the journal's responsibility. The person reporting is acknowledged.
  2. Gathering evidence – The editor reviews the manuscript, reviews, and data; checks similarity reports; and may consult reviewers or experts.
  3. Contacting the authors – The corresponding author (and, where appropriate, all authors) are informed of the concern and given an opportunity to respond, normally within 14–30 days.
  4. Referral to the institution – If the authors' response is unsatisfactory or no response is received, the journal may contact the authors' institution, funder, or relevant authority and ask them to investigate. The journal does not carry out investigations that are the institution's responsibility.
  5. Outcome – Depending on the findings, the journal may: dismiss the allegation; request clarification or a correction; reject the manuscript (if not yet published); publish an expression of concern; retract the article; and/or ban the authors from submitting to the journal for a set period.

Principles

  • Allegations are treated in confidence. Information is shared only with those who need it to resolve the case.
  • Authors are presumed innocent until misconduct is established, and are always given the chance to respond.
  • Whistle-blowers acting in good faith are protected.

The journal keeps a record of each case and its outcome.