Post-Publication Discussion

Jurnal Pendidikan Matematika welcomes scholarly discussion of published articles. Open, constructive debate helps maintain the accuracy and integrity of the scientific record, in line with the COPE Core Practice on post-publication discussions and corrections.

How to comment on a published article

  • Letter to the Editor – Readers may submit a short commentary (maximum 1,000 words and 12 references) on an article published in JUPITEK. Letters should be sent to the OJS with the subject “Letter to the Editor – [article title]”.
  • Author reply – If a letter is accepted, the authors of the original article are invited to respond. Where possible, the letter and the reply are published together.
  • Informal feedback – Questions or comments that do not require publication may be emailed directly to the corresponding author (whose address is printed on the article) or to the editorial office.

Editorial handling

  • Letters are reviewed by the editors and, where needed, by an external reviewer. They must be relevant, evidence-based, and respectful. Personal attacks, defamatory statements, and commercial promotion will not be accepted.
  • Letters that raise possible errors or misconduct are handled under the journal's Correction and Retraction or Allegation of Research Misconduct policies.

Discussions outside the journal

The journal monitors substantive concerns raised on other platforms (for example, PubPeer, social media, or academic networks). When such concerns raise serious questions about a JUPITEK article, the editors will investigate them in the same way as a direct report.